New: Tennis Directory — Top 10 academies, camps, resorts & getaways →
Play Ace Court — our free arcade tennis game →
Featured: Teo Davidov, the two-forehand phenom →
Join the Big Tennis newsletter — free weekly tips & news →
Tennis Tips

ATP Finals Pattern Note 2: Tuesday — the McEnroe Group Deciders

By Moose November 17, 2026 9 min read

Tuesday decided the shape of the McEnroe Group — and it did it the way Sunday did: with the serve. Arthur Fils came from a set down to beat Rafael Jodar 4-6, 6-2, 6-2 in the afternoon. Alexander Zverev beat Ben Shelton 6-2, 7-6(4) at night, and with it became the first man through to the semi-finals. Two matches, two lessons, and one chart I still owe you — more on that below.

Here’s what the seven patterns from the preview actually looked like on Tuesday.

1. Serve +1: Twenty-Five Points in a Row

If Sunday was the serve doing the talking, Tuesday was the serve refusing to give the microphone back. From the end of the first set to 6-6 in the second, Zverev won 25 points in a row behind his serve — five consecutive love holds — before a Shelton return winner finally ended the run. He lost only two points on serve in the entire second set, won 22 of 23 points behind his first serve in that set, and finished the match at 88 percent of first-serve points won (38 of 43), with 14 aces and no double faults. Across the whole match he dropped just 10 points on serve.

Fils told the same story in the afternoon: 79 percent of first-serve points won (26 of 33), and only four points lost on his serve in the whole second set. Jodar, for contrast, hit nine aces and still won just 63 percent of his first-serve points — the serve alone isn’t the pattern. It’s the serve plus the next ball.

The honest note, and I won’t dress it up: the reports still don’t chart the +1 targets, so I can’t tell you exactly where Zverev’s first ball after the serve went. That’s now two days running, and it’s the one chart this series keeps promising and not delivering. What the numbers do show is the effect — Shelton made 24 unforced errors to Zverev’s 10, and won 55 points to Zverev’s 74. When the serve sets the table that cleanly, the +1 ball doesn’t have to be a winner. It just has to keep the other man defending.

Borrow it: Same homework as Sunday — pick your +1 target before you toss. And if you want the honest version of the drill: serve, then hit the first ball to the spot you chose, even if the return is comfortable. Zverev’s 25 in a row weren’t 25 winners. They were 25 points where the server decided what happened next.

2. Two Return Positions: Still No Read

This one stays open, and I owe you the plain version of why. No report from Tuesday says where Zverev stood to return Shelton’s second serve — not how far in, not how far back, not whether it changed between the first and second sets. The chart Note 1 promised is still uncharted.

What the scoreboard does say: Zverev’s return did its damage early — he broke Shelton in the opening game, then again in the fifth, and the first set was over in 38 minutes. Then Shelton’s serve held its ground: at 4-4 in the second, Zverev earned two break points at 15-40 and Shelton saved both, one with a decisive volley, one with an ace. Shelton hit 15 aces to Zverev’s 14. So the return won the first set and couldn’t find the door in the second — but where Zverev’s feet were when he did it, I don’t know, and I won’t guess.

Borrow it: Thursday is the last chance to chart this one in the group stage — Zverev against Fils, Shelton against Jodar. Watch the feet on second-serve returns, not just the result. The position is the tell; the break point is just the receipt.

3. Crosscourt Until You Earn the Line: Fils Mixed, Then Struck

The afternoon match is the best example of this pattern all week, because Fils explained it himself. He lost the first set playing, in his words, “a bit too much in the rhythm” — Jodar’s rhythm. “Rafa is unbelievable player. When he has his rhythm, he’s one of the best in the world. So I tried to mix, to find a way to manage, to be a bit more aggressive and then a bit more defensive and to try to make him move. Otherwise, if I’m the one running, I’m going to lose a lot of points.”

His coaches, Goran Ivanisevic and Ivan Cinkus, were calling the same thing from the box: “cover this angle, cover this angle, try to mix a bit more, try to change the serve.” And the mix produced the two line changes that decided the match. In the decider, two Jodar errors teed Fils up and he broke for 2-1 with a stunning inside-in forehand winner. Then he broke again with an incredible backhand pass on the stretch, and served it out to 15. Crosscourt to earn it, line to finish it — the pattern, run twice in one set.

The first set is the warning label on the same pattern. Fils had the first chances — two break points at 1-1, a third at 4-4 in a long game with several deuces — and converted none of them. He put only 38 percent of his first serves in during that set and hit a single winner to Jodar’s eight. Serving at 4-5 he fell behind 15-40, saved the first set point, but not the second. You don’t get to change direction until you’ve earned the rally. In set one, Fils hadn’t.

Borrow it: Fils’s own words are the drill — mix aggressive and defensive, make him move. The line change works when you’ve moved your opponent first. Fils’s two breaks in the decider both came after he’d made Jodar run.

4. The First Step In: Shelton Tried Everything. Zverev Passed Him.

The AP’s one-line summary of the night match is the whole pattern in miniature: “Ben Shelton tried coming forward. He tried staying back. He served-and-volleyed. He resorted to coming in on his second shot. None of it was quite enough.”

One forward move did work. At 4-4 in the second set, 15-40 down, Shelton saved a break point with a decisive volley — the approach done right, on a ball that earned it, finished at the net. But the night’s last forward move is the one that ended the match. Zverev led the tiebreak 6-4, one match point, and finished it with a forehand passing shot on the run. “I was very clear-minded of what I wanted to do with that ball and it was perfect,” he said afterwards. The pass is the tax on coming in. Pay it, or don’t come in.

Shelton was honest about the rest of it: “It’s always difficult to play against Sascha, the way that he serves, the way he returns, the weight on his shots. I was disappointed with how I played from the baseline today.” When the forward moves don’t work and the baseline doesn’t work, that’s not a tactics problem. That’s a Zverev problem.

COURT DIAGRAM — “The Match-Point Pass”: Overhead view of the court, Zverev at the bottom, stretched wide to his forehand side on the run. Shelton forward, inside the court. One thick arrow: Zverev’s forehand pass, arrowed past the net man. Label it: “Match point, tiebreak 6-4 — the pass that punishes the man who comes in.” A caption underneath: “The reports call it a forehand passing shot on the run; they don’t chart which lane it took, so the diagram shows the decision, not the exact line.”

Borrow it: Come in on a ball that earns it — Shelton’s 4-4 volley is your model. And practise the pass as a decision, not a reaction: Zverev knew what he wanted to do with that ball before he hit it. Clear-minded beats fast feet.

5. The Reset Ball: Still Not Seen — But the Mix Showed Up

Nothing in Tuesday’s reports showed a reset ball — the high, heavy, boring save that buys three seconds. That’s three days running now, and the reason is the same: this event is serve-dominated, and the stretched-wide, off-balance rallies where the reset lives are rare in Turin.

The closest thing to it came from Fils, and it’s worth naming because it’s the reset’s cousin: the deliberate mix. “A bit more aggressive and then a bit more defensive” — the defensive half of that sentence is a player choosing not to force the issue, buying time, making the other man move instead. It’s not a reset ball. But it’s the same decision: when you’re losing the rally, change the rally instead of hitting harder.

The afternoon’s real story wasn’t a shot at all. It was a body. Jodar faded physically from the middle of the second set — a medical timeout, medicine mixed into his water bottle, a banana, a gel and an energy bar at the next changeover. “I felt that I couldn’t compete,” he said afterwards. “Physically, I wasn’t at the level today, especially in the last two sets.” He refused to blame the court: “It’s the same for everyone.” Fils won six of the final seven games. Sometimes the pattern that decides a match is the one off the court — the season catching up with a 20-year-old in his first Finals.

Borrow it: The reset is still on the watch list. But Fils’s mix is the takeaway you can use tomorrow: when the other man’s rhythm is beating you, don’t hit harder — hit different.

6. Big Points: The Tiebreak Belonged to the Clear Mind

Zverev led the tiebreak 3-1, then 5-3, earned two match points at 6-4 and converted the first with that forehand pass. “I feel like I played a very good tiebreak,” he said. He did — and the clearest evidence is the quote: he knew exactly what he wanted to do with the match-point ball before he hit it. That’s the big-point pattern in one sentence. The banker isn’t a shot. It’s a decision made before the point starts.

The rest of the night’s big points cut both ways. Shelton’s two saves at 4-4 — volley, then ace — kept him alive for the tiebreak. Zverev saved the only two break points he faced all match. And in the afternoon, Fils lived the other side of it: down 15-40 serving at 4-5 in the first set, he saved one set point but not the second, and the set was gone. Big points don’t forgive a first set played at 38 percent first serves.

Borrow it twice: Build your banker — one serve-plus-one you’d trust at 4-5, 30-40 — and rehearse it until it’s boring. And make the decision before the point, the way Zverev did on match point. “I was very clear-minded” is a skill, not a mood.

7. The Tiebreak: Tested — and the Server Won It

The pattern is live now, not on the watch list. Monday delivered the tournament’s first tiebreak — Medvedev over Cobolli, 7-6(4) — and Tuesday delivered the second, Zverev over Shelton by the same 7-4 margin. Both went to the man whose serve had been the story of the match. That’s not a coincidence; it’s the shape of this event. On a fast indoor court, the tiebreak is a serving contest with a coin toss at the end — and the server who has been untouchable all night usually stays untouchable for seven more points.

Zverev’s own verdict on the night: “The first set was close to perfect.” He knew the danger of letting Shelton get confident — “If he’s playing with confidence, it’s really, really tough against him” — so he took the first set before Shelton could believe in it. “It’s a benefit to be ahead against Ben because he’s so powerful.” Get ahead early, hold serve, let the tiebreak come to you. That’s the whole match plan in three sentences.

The Group After Tuesday

Zverev sits 2-0 and qualified, with a match to spare — four sets won, none lost. Fils and Shelton are both 1-1, and Jodar is 0-2 and all but out. Thursday decides the second semi-final spot: Zverev against Fils, Shelton against Jodar. Wednesday belongs to the Lendl Group — Alcaraz against Medvedev, Cobolli against Tiafoe — and if the serve keeps behaving the way it has, expect another night where the first two balls decide everything.

Tuesday’s lesson, in one line: the serve won the day again, the tiebreak is live now, and the clearest head in the building won the biggest point of the night. That’s not a 140 mph secret. It’s a decision — and it’s one you can make on Thursday.

Pattern notes continue after each day’s play. Next: Thursday’s McEnroe Group deciders — and the chart I still owe you, Zverev’s return position on second serve.

Share Post Share Email

Moose

Big Tennis contributor. Founder Rich Benvin is a former ATP pro, WTA coach and CEO of Mass Density, Inc. About Big Tennis →

Enjoyed this? Get the weekly Big Tennis recap.

Free weekly tennis news, coaching tips, drills and games — plus Teo Davidov updates. Pick what you want; unsubscribe anytime.

Choose your emails

Join the conversation

Big Tennis
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.